Showing posts with label Motivation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Motivation. Show all posts

Sunday, January 22, 2012

Creative Destruction or Simply Destruction?

Sybille Sachs highlighted in her last post (New path to innovation) some of the questionable business-practices surrounding corporate cost-cutting. I would like to provide here a concrete example I experienced in my years in the corporate world and further consider the short-term and long-term consequences of such company reorganizations and cost-cutting.
In the 1990s I had the pleasure to work for a rapidly growing, privately held start-up company in the medical laser industry. I use the word “pleasure” with deliberation, as the motivation, dedication and team-spirit were wonderful – and that despite working long hours, not having any huge bonuses or enticing stock-options as carrot-sticks dangling in front of our noses. The morale in the company was high because input (in terms of resources, effort and creativity) was readily recognizable in concrete results.

Then the company was purchased by a publicly traded corporation.
Within months a “reorganization” was initiated that resulted in the suspension of research projects, the dissolution of numerous prospering business relationships and the attrition of - in several rounds - employees. All this was undertaken in the name of “business consolidation” and the concomitant cost-cutting. The investors and stock market loved it: the corporation’s share price exuberantly jumped in response.

On the “inside”, however, the result was exactly the opposite: a sharp drop in employee motivation and rising cynicism, erosion of trust and know-how and – eventually – evaporating financial returns by the corporate subsidiary we had become. Indeed, within 18 months employee count had roughly gone down by a third and a company that boasted 35 million dollars in revenues, posted at best half of that number. The share price of the corporation subsequently dropped from (if I correctly recall) about 40 dollars a share to only 4 dollars a share!
Granted, a multitude of factors played into this precipitous drop in share price. But that these “cost-cutting” activities contributed in some form to the financial fallout in the stock market is self-evident. Less evident, however, are the larger implications of such “cost-cutting” strategies.

First, despite any strong personal penchant for valuing people over profits and striving towards not making ends justify means, it must be recognized that on a larger, macro-economic scale, such “destructivity” could indeed be part of Schumpeters’ (in)famous creative destruction. The American “churn” model of hire and fire, while often with terrible personal, social and innovation costs, does (or at least did…) permit considerable labor flexibility, speed of economic rejuvenation and knowledge transfer as employees and resources shuttle from company to company. For me, after having been let go in the second wave of attrition meant that I suddenly had the needed motivation to get out of the corporate world into an environment more suitable to my aptitudes and taste.
Second, however, what may be “creative” at one place (or time or for any one person), may not be thus in another. For a large and fluid labor market as the USA, the churn model may have been a viable option. For a more segmented and embedded labor pool as the EU, it seems less so. And for a very small and very much socially rooted labor pool as Switzerland, the “churn model” would have catastrophic socio-economic and likely also political consequences.

Not surprisingly, this is indeed what one discovers, as was once again poignantly illustrated to me during a recent lunch I had with a scientist at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, who was involved in a start-up company with a footing in both Switzerland and the USA: he complained about how difficult it was to get start-up funding and start-up employees in Switzerland as compared to the USA. He readily understood, however, that the American model would be unsuitable for Switzerland, as the capacity to sustain “churn” was significantly smaller for tiny Switzerland. Nevertheless, both Switzerland and the US have highly productive and competitive economies, each remarkably well adapted to their particular socio-economic and geographic “biotope”.
Indeed, we know from biological organisms as well as biotopes that change is vital for the survival of an organism or a species. The challenge for all organisms (and biotopes) is to find that “sweet-spot”, sometimes referred to the “edge of chaos”, where change – and thus innovation – is maximized without sliding into chaotic destruction. Much the same may hold for an economy. But while one may well entertain such questions about an entire economy, it is another matter entirely to what extent such “creative destruction” or “churn” is to be a desirable for individual human beings.

If humans are to be ends in themselves, any corporate strategy that facilely treats employees as mere cost centers risks devaluing human life per se. And history is unfortunately replete with examples of where that can lead to…

Manuel Heer Dawson

 

Monday, January 16, 2012


New path to innovation
In an article titled “The Pharmaceutical Industry Faces a Horror Year,“ a Zurich newspaper (http://snipurl.com/21qcbem) writes, that leading pharmaceutical firms like Pfizer, Sanofi as well as Novartis are facing the loss of patent protection for important top products this year, and are therefore facing major revenue losses. Interestingly, these firms are confronting the situation with drastic personnel cuts in different areas, which includes such as how to respond to clinical developments. Cost saving has to begin immediately. However, proceeding this way raises questions.

First, investigations show
[i] that personnel cuts, particularly in the long run, do not bring about the desired success, unless a strategic reorientation occurs at the same time. In an extensive empirical study the authors were able to show that the size of the employee cuts is not a factor in explaining the post-downsized performance.

A further point concerns “survivor sickness” studies
[ii]. They show that personnel cuts have an array of negative consequences, also for those who remain at the firm: “Research indicates that survivors exhibit a plethora of problems, such as demotivation, cynicism, insecurity, demoralization, and a significant decline in organizational commitment”[iii]. One also speaks of the difficulty in diagnosing dysfunctional side effects of personnel cuts. They often lead to slumps in productivity.

In addition, if one considers that in the knowledge oriented society of today, knowledge is often a more important success factor than capital. There is then the danger that for every cut in personnel, the know-how networks will be destroyed and important knowledge bearers will be discarded. Indispensible resources for future core competences may be lost.

It is also striking that the only reasons given for the personnel cuts are the costs, but never the revenue side of the coin. By strengthening R&D capacity, setbacks could be absorbed. Is it therefore sensible to dismiss people in the area of research and development? Wouldn’t it make more sense to encourage targeted cooperation with stakeholders that possess special knowledge, in order to stimulate the innovative productivity of the firm’s own R&D?
[iv].

Also in our own empirical investigations, we have always found impressive examples of cases, where firms that work together with their stakeholders have been able to substantially increase their license to innovate (see Sachs, Rühli 2011, page 114 ff). In this regard an interview partner (page 118) mentions, “The suppliers are creative and often involved as they try to find new solutions for the market….They act as accelerators who give us new ideas….And very often the supplier is also a strategic thought leader….”

Especially in the area of innovation, firms should not only engage in professional stakeholder management when the turnover drops. Our examples show in fact that not only the firms improve their license to innovate but also the involved stakeholders, which motivates them to further cooperation.

Based on the above, we can conclude that managers, practicing personnel cuts with the argument of saving costs, have an obligation to demonstrate that they also have the above mentioned consequences under control, e.g. the benefits. It should be carefully examined if the multifaceted disadvantages and damage of personnel cuts are not, in fact much higher than the advantage of short-term cost savings.
Sybille Sachs





[i] Garry D. Bruton, Kay Keels,  Christopher L: Shook, Downsizing the Firm: Answering the Strategic Question, Academy of Management Executive 1996, Vol. 10, No2, pp- 38-45
[ii] E.g. Firns, I., Travaglione, A. and O'Neill, G. (2006), Absenteeism in times of rapid organizational change. Strategic Change, 15: 113–128. doi: 10.1002/jsc.757
[iii] Ibid, p. 2
[iv] E.g. with lead-users, see Christopher Lettl, Cornelius Herstatt, Hans Georg Gemuenden,, Learning from users for radical innovation, International Journal of Technology Management, 2006, 33 (1), 25-45

Sunday, January 8, 2012


The Power of Positive Motivation

In various messages at the turn of the year, the sense of community was mentioned as the primary basis for society, which needs again to be promoted in order to counterbalance self-interest as the mainspring of human behavior.
When a person concentrates on his self-interest, as foreseen in the concept of human beings as homo oeconomicus, then he is mainly concerned with himself and his needs. Others very quickly become rivals. In his professional life he is motivated to use his knowledge and ability to earn as much money as possible, so as to better satisfy his own needs.  According to a popular expression, “The more he has, the more he wants.”

If, however, our understanding of human beings causes us to see our relations with others as being of primary importance, then we will carry our knowledge and ability into our relationships. In this way, knowledge and ability can be combined innovatively and developed. In this context Erich Fromm distinguishes between active and passive motivation, and emphasizes that human beings need to interact with other human beings primarily with active and not only with passive "motivation." Passive motivation focuses on controlling an interaction, for instance to protect property. The output of these interactions can be described as "having." In contrast, active motivation considers "being" as "process, activity and movement." Fromm describes motivation as an activity between two human beings as follows: "He gives him of his joy, of his interest, of his understanding, of his knowledge, of his humor, of his sadness – of all expressions and manifestations of that which is alive in him." (Fromm, E. (1956). The Art of Loving. New York, NY: Harper & Row, p.24). With respect to knowledge, Fromm offers the following examples to contrast active and passive motivation within human interaction: "Having knowledge is taking and keeping possession of available knowledge (information); knowing is functional and serves only as a means in the process of productive thinking." (Fromm, E. (1997) To Have or to Be? London: Continuum, p. 33).

In our studies of stakeholder relations in practice, we found numerous examples in which Fromm’s concept of positive motivation led to innovative, new solutions. (See chapter 7, Sachs, Rühli 2011). The basis of this motivation is the desire to respect and understand and thereby to replace going solo with a sense of community.

Sybille Sachs


Saturday, December 17, 2011


Dare to care

During a recent conservation with the leaders of various business units in a multinational corporation it became clear how different leaders are used to perceive and treat their employees. One of the participants told the following story: One of his employees was undergoing a difficult personal situation in her family circle. Finally she could no longer carry the burden; so she told to the manager that she was no longer able to perform in her usual manner as she had to unexpectedly take care of a problem in her family. The manger who esteemed this employee and her extraordinary performance decided to support her. Therefore he suggested that she could give priority to her personal problems for a certain time. He restrained from giving her a time limit or any other kind of specifications and restrictions.  
The reaction of the employee was overwhelming. She voluntarily informed him how she resolved her situation step by step and she was obviously even more devoted to her work after this experience than before. The manager himself decided that in the future he would encourage his staff to be open to him regarding their personal situation.

This story is probably not an exception but it confirms important insights we can gain out of studies that are done in the area of “work and care”. People are more motivated to work if they are respected not only as a human resource but as a human being. Doing business is not a purely economic affair but also a human one. And finally, considering employees as human beings provides  not only positive effects in motivation but such employees are more than 30 % in a better physical condition, 25 % have a reduction in stress,  5 % are sleeping better. Due to their improved  work-life balance an increase in productivity of over 30 % could be ascertained  (see for example  Bright Horizon (2010).  Enhanced Employee Health, Well-Being, and Engagement through Dependent Care Supports).
With respect to a systematic approach to motivate employees and other stakeholders to contribute their resources for a firm’s value creation, it is important to keep in mind that stakeholders are ends and not means. This was emphasized by an interviewee as follows: “Employees as stakeholders play an integral role because if you treat employees as interchangeable commodities that can just be switched in and out, you're never going to get the transfer of knowledge; and you're never going to achieve the real efficiency that you can with the development of knowledge and expertise” (see chapter 6 in Sachs, Rühli 2011). Last year the annual meeting of the Academy of Management was guided by the motto “Dare to care” to explore new approaches in the field of strategy and organization. Based on the above stated experiences and studies I suggest that one of the guiding principles for new narratives of leadership should be “Dare to care”.

Sybille Sachs