Showing posts with label Work-Life Balance. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Work-Life Balance. Show all posts

Tuesday, February 19, 2013

The Separation of Work and Life

To illustrate complex issues, I frequently draw on the work-life balance as a relevant and timely problem affecting virtually everybody. Usually, conversations are about how to find effective private strategies and good public policies to facilitate an individual and sustainable balance between the two parts of how people spend their time: work and life. There are many different practices applied or perspectives taken, and, for the sake of complexity, I would like to add another question: Is a separation of work and life always meaning- or purposeful (another more logical question would be, if comparing work and life is somewhat similar to make a distinction between apples and fruits…)?

By using the expression "work-life balance", we are implicitly relying on the idea that work and life are something different, something separated from each other. Aside from the logical fact that life includes work, I think it is a worthwhile exercise to question this tacit assumption of a dichotomy between those domains. Quite often, the separation of work and life is regarded as healthy or generally good in an imperative and moral manner. "You should enjoy your leisure time!" or "Could you please stop talking about work during your recreational activities?" are common expressions in this context. I hope that the pressure to enjoy one’s leisure time is not as high as the pressure to separate work and life…

My point is that life and work cannot easily be separated. Do you think that activities like working, living, loving, being a soccer fan, having your friends’ messages on your mobile, chatting privately during work time, having a swim during lunchtime, and so on, are easily separated into the work-life dichotomy? The domains of work and life influence each other and we are not machines being able to throw a lever to shut off life while working.

If the domains of work and life interact, why do we always assume that work negatively affects life? Could it not be that work is positively affecting life, for example by giving meaning and sense through purposeful actions? Many persons define themselves through their professions, while having their personal identities at stake when talking about work.

I think the best way to think about the relationship between work and life is to perceive these two domains as mutually supportive. Bringing in parts of one’s personal skills and knowledge, personalities, even problems, into the work domain enriches the professional environment. On the other hand, there is also a transfer of professional benefits to worker’s private lives. Competencies learned during working time can be used quite effectively in different settings related to the private domain.

Therefore, a separation between life and work does not further the search for a meaningful balance between the two domains. In my opinion, the two domains have to be integrated into a holistic perspective that brings in the best of both worlds under a common purpose. Life will be much easier and more meaningful if we do not have to separate work and leisure time obsessively.
 

Wednesday, August 15, 2012

Switching perspectives

If we talk about stakeholder relationships, the most common reaction of people is to think about a firm and the different groups which are affected by the corresponding business activities. These stakeholders are usually named as financiers, customers, suppliers, employees, the communities and so on. By this means we talk about stakeholders defined by their functional relationships with a firm, which is situated in the center of its stakeholder relationships. Further, the usual way of thinking about stakeholder management is on how to elaborate positive relationships with stakeholders to create as much economic value as possible.

In this blog post I would like to address two rather unusual ways of thinking about stakeholder management by making use of the example of employees’ work-life balance as an independent issue. In the context of this issue, the traditional defined stakeholder categories of a firm are no longer of much use to capture the essential features of the employees’ work-life balance. To assess what is of real importance for people, a firm’s decision makers have to switch perspectives to find out which groups have a real stake in the issue of the work-life balance. The traditional stakeholder category of employees then becomes more fine-grained, for example as mothers, fathers, daughters, sons, part-time workers and so on. By switching the perspective from a functional firm-centered to an issue-based view, decision makers are able to identify a much broader, and arguably more useful, set of stakeholders related to the firms’ activities.

But how are those newly recognized stakeholders related to a firm’s value creation? I think part of the answer arises from a too narrow understanding of value in an economic sense. It is easy for decision makers to conceptualize economic value creation in traditional firm-stakeholder relationships, as those ties are, as described above, functionally defined. But from a stakeholder’s perspective, there are other ways of understanding what “value” actually consists of. Indeed, regarding the issue of the work-life balance, stakeholder groups like mothers or fathers acknowledge the results related to their relationship with a firm, for example the accessibility to corporate childcare services, but also the possibility to work part-time in a managerial function. However, besides those extrinsic values related to economic or non-economic goods or services in a stakeholder relationship, employees are also seeking for more intrinsically motivated results. For example, employees also appreciate the psychological result of job satisfaction, as they are recognized and esteemed by the firm’s decision makers regarding their stake in the issue of work-life balance, thus for example as mothers and fathers.

In my opinion, managerial decision-makers can realize a much broader potential for value creation if they not only rely on a firm-centered approach to create economic value together with their functional stakeholders. Switching perspectives to identify the stake different groups have in a focal issue and recognizing both the corresponding extrinsic and intrinsic results of stakeholder relationships will then lead to an enhanced mutual value creation of a firm with its stakeholders.

Thomas Schneider

Sunday, December 25, 2011


 
Leaders are human beings

Leadership seems not to be divisible; it absorbs the person totally. This credo is accepted in business but also in politics. We experienced this already four years ago when Barack Obama was elected President. Even though he had small children at the time, there was barely any discussion of how he could carry out the two responsibilities, namely the Presidency and fatherhood. But if Michelle Obama had been elected President, certainly everybody would have been discussing this matter. The difference in judging the same situation between a man and a woman is even more astonishing, as both are well educated and successful in their profession.

Recently a similar situation occurred in Switzerland. A 39 year old (young!) man, Alain Berset, was elected as Swiss Federal Council.  His wife is also very successful in her profession. The couple has three young children. Again there was little public discussion that Alain Berset as Federal Council will barely have time to see his three children. We – as a culture - obviously think it is more important that our leaders carry out their professional tasks full-time, rather than that they spend part of their time with family duties. We consider that their duties lie in their professional life and not in their private life as human beings. This is especially true for men.

This understanding asks either for specific personalities and values for leaders, or that failing, it accepts that leaders simply bear the stress due to the tension between their professional and private lives. What is however mostly overlooked is that the values and personalities of such leaders also influence the understanding of leadership in society, which thus far emphasizes an instrumental and not human oriented worldview. Moreover, it hinders men to think about their multiple roles, and how they might coordinate them with their partners.

But why should it not be thinkable that an American President or a Swiss Federal Council work part time? And more provocatively, that a man actually asks to work part time as President or Federal Council? Are the experiences of parenthood so negligible that we prefer our leaders to just be professionals?

If we don't start to see our leaders more as human beings, we can’t expect that they will be humanly oriented. We should change our priorities in this respect. In case studies we carried out with students at the University of Zurich and also in other studies (see e.g. Shellenback, K. (2004). Child Care & Parent Productivity: Making the Business Case), it becomes obvious that shared leadership in firms, leads to higher motivation but also to additional competences based on the experiences of parenthood. These studies also make clear that we need more leaders who are asking for shared leadership and more examples of good practices. So let us look for new ways of leadership in 2012. I am looking forward to your experiences on our blog.

Sybille Sachs

Saturday, December 17, 2011


Dare to care

During a recent conservation with the leaders of various business units in a multinational corporation it became clear how different leaders are used to perceive and treat their employees. One of the participants told the following story: One of his employees was undergoing a difficult personal situation in her family circle. Finally she could no longer carry the burden; so she told to the manager that she was no longer able to perform in her usual manner as she had to unexpectedly take care of a problem in her family. The manger who esteemed this employee and her extraordinary performance decided to support her. Therefore he suggested that she could give priority to her personal problems for a certain time. He restrained from giving her a time limit or any other kind of specifications and restrictions.  
The reaction of the employee was overwhelming. She voluntarily informed him how she resolved her situation step by step and she was obviously even more devoted to her work after this experience than before. The manager himself decided that in the future he would encourage his staff to be open to him regarding their personal situation.

This story is probably not an exception but it confirms important insights we can gain out of studies that are done in the area of “work and care”. People are more motivated to work if they are respected not only as a human resource but as a human being. Doing business is not a purely economic affair but also a human one. And finally, considering employees as human beings provides  not only positive effects in motivation but such employees are more than 30 % in a better physical condition, 25 % have a reduction in stress,  5 % are sleeping better. Due to their improved  work-life balance an increase in productivity of over 30 % could be ascertained  (see for example  Bright Horizon (2010).  Enhanced Employee Health, Well-Being, and Engagement through Dependent Care Supports).
With respect to a systematic approach to motivate employees and other stakeholders to contribute their resources for a firm’s value creation, it is important to keep in mind that stakeholders are ends and not means. This was emphasized by an interviewee as follows: “Employees as stakeholders play an integral role because if you treat employees as interchangeable commodities that can just be switched in and out, you're never going to get the transfer of knowledge; and you're never going to achieve the real efficiency that you can with the development of knowledge and expertise” (see chapter 6 in Sachs, Rühli 2011). Last year the annual meeting of the Academy of Management was guided by the motto “Dare to care” to explore new approaches in the field of strategy and organization. Based on the above stated experiences and studies I suggest that one of the guiding principles for new narratives of leadership should be “Dare to care”.

Sybille Sachs